The chapter that called to me was Chapter 34, specifically one part. When asked about AI being a revolution to reflect/reimagine benefits to all, the writer answers, “If it can be, libraries—still standing tall—will have an important role by broadening our individual and collective experiences, freeing us from narrow visions, and resourcing our realization of greater ends. As archives, they will provide us with sources of hope; as sites of anticipation, they will provide us with signs of hope; and as places of action, they will provide structures that help us realize our hopes. In a library, one may discover and find oneself in—and perhaps even transformed by—a shared and hopeful narrative about the greater purposes that create and sustain such an enduring institution” (Paulus 2026). Libraries give everyone the free will to choose what they learn, what they read, and who they become—without an algorithm determining their path. This passage stood out to me because it made me think of the video we watched earlier about how algorithms are choosing what news we see and our search results. AI is constantly predicting our behavior and trapping us into personalized bubbles. However, the library protects our agency, fosters spontaneous discovery, and reminds us that technology should serve higher purposes, not replace them.
While generative Artificial Intelligence offers exciting capabilities—from streamlining routine search tasks to brainstorming ideas—it also carries subtle risks. As highlighted in The Algorithmic Self (2025) reliance on predictive models continuously shapes human self-concept and narrows individual agency. Joseph’s research states, “Recommendation algorithms, predictive language models, and behavior-monitoring AI capabilities now not only present us with what we might consume but with how we ought to feel, how we ought to think, and even how we ought to self-categorize.” While I appreciate the practical benefits of AI in my daily life, libraries must make sure technology remains a tool instead of a dictator of human thought. I’m pretty sure we’ve all seen how this plays out when we let technology become a dictator. Did anyone else watch the movie Smart House on the Disney channel? Sci-fi stories have been warning us about this for years! Joking aside, libraries remain one of the few places where you can stumble upon a new favorite book purely by chance, protecting our ability to think independently outside the algorithmic bubble.
While I appreciate how convenient AI can be, I can’t ignore what it’s actually costing our planet. We tend to think of tech as this invisible thing, but running these AI models takes a massive toll on the physical world. Massive data centers consume huge amounts of energy and gulp down millions of gallons of freshwater every day just to keep servers cool. I enjoy creating AI images to match novels, but the environmental cost is eye-opening. As noted in the report The Environmental Cost of Artificial Intelligence: Carbon, Water, and Land Footprints (2026), “the energy required to generate a typical AI image is enough to power a 10-watt LED bulb for 17 minutes, and the energy required for a high-complexity AI video is sufficient to run that same bulb for 42 hours. Similarly, the electricity associated water footprint is about two tablespoons (29 mL) for a single image, but jumps to 4.1 liters for a complex video—almost equivalent to a two-day drinking water need for one person.” Chapter 34 talks about signs of hope, but the hope for our future has to include taking care of the environment. As librarians, we have to look at tech ethics. The American Library Association’s Guidance on the Use of Artificial Intelligence in Libraries urges institutions to prioritize environmental sustainability and the public good. To me, that means libraries should ask the hard questions about what technology costs our natural world.
Looking at both the algorithmic bubbles and the heavy environmental toll, it’s clear to me that basic information literacy isn’t enough anymore. In Beyond Information Literacy, Nicole Murph argues that libraries need to focus on critical AI literacy. To me, that means librarians will need to teach patrons to question how algorithms steer our thinking while also recognizing the real water and energy consumed behind every click. Libraries will need to help communities make conscious, thoughtful choices so that humans have free will instead of having our choices made for us. That’s what ‘finding oneself’ in a library is really all about in the age of AI.
References
American Library Association. (2024). Ala.Org. https://www.ala.org/tools/standards-and-guidelines/guidance- use-artificial-intelligence-libraries
Joseph, J. (2025). The algorithmic self: how AI is reshaping human identity, introspection, and agency. Frontiers in Psychology, 16. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1645795
Murph, N. (2025). Beyond Information Literacy: Exploring AI’s Impact on Labor in Academic Libraries. Digital Commons at Loyola Marymount University and Loyola Law School. https://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/librarian_pubs/159/
Pariser, E. (2011). Beware online “filter bubbles”. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8ofWFx525s
Paulus, M. J. J. (2026). Hope in the Library.
The Environmental Cost of Artificial Intelligence: Carbon, Water, and Land Footprints. (2026). In United Nations University. https://unu.edu/inweh/collection/environmental-cost-of-AIs-Enrgy-Use-Carbon-water-and-land-footprints
I love your argument. Isn’t it so true? Yes, our information literacy role is moving beyond, no doubt! Such great critical thinking here, the type of thinking we MUST continue to institute in our students!
ReplyDelete