In chapter 4, "Why Libraries?”, Paulus (2025) provides a cautiously optimistic response to the question, “Do we really even need libraries these days?” (p. 21). That question grabbed my attention. Perhaps people feel the need to ask because the assumption is that with the advancement of AI, society will eventually no longer need libraries. There is certainly no ignoring or doing away with it; AI is not theoretical, it’s here. As Paulus (2025) writes, “AI has become a ubiquitous and general-purpose technology like the steam engine, electricity, and the digital computer” (p. 23). And as a library student, with a growing understanding of just how crucial and beneficial libraries are and have been to society, I wonder why people see AI as a threat to the existence of libraries. Regardless of how advanced technology becomes, society will continue to need trusted stewards and preservationists of our shared culture and, therefore, well-organized and equitable access to it. Paulus (2025) points out, “Not all institutions age well, but the library has proven itself to be not just relevant but crucial for millennia. It is also one of the few highly trusted and valued institutions in our society” (P. 22). While libraries remain a staple in democratic society, that does not mean they can afford to stagnate. Like with the adoption of the internet, libraries will have to adjust and find their equilibrium with AI. And like other advancements in technology before it, AI comes with its own challenges, but those challenges should be met with, as Paulus puts it, “sufficient human responsibility and accountability” (p. 24). He writes:
The Library[…] has [a] unique role and responsibility as intelligent technologies advance. By designing new automated information processes as well as new human information practices, libraries can help shape a good information environment for both natural and artificial information agents—an environment that is aligned with and advances human values and the hopes they inspire (2025, p. 24).
Librarians and library patrons should take solace in the library’s ability to evolve with the times and remain not just useful but crucial to society. It’s been said that AI is here to stay, but so are libraries, and now is the time to carefully and thoughtfully consider how libraries can continue to assure ethical, responsible, and equitable use and access to resources as we move forward with and, hopefully, not against AI.
AI and its place in our future cannot be considered without first addressing the data center in the room: is AI ethical? Libraries and librarians serve the good of the public and are widely considered champions of truth and democracy. As it stands, AI is functioning in direct opposition to those fundamental principles. Like with book bans, librarians find themselves caught between a rock and a hard place. On one hand, is it ethical to engage with AI, and, on the other, does rejecting AI inequitably limit patrons’ access to a new technology?
There is evidence supporting the claim that AI is not only unethical but dangerous. There is no shortage of new articles and studies revealing the harm AI is causing to the environment, employment, our privacy, and to books. In a PBS article covering the pollution caused by AI and data centers, Borenstein (2026) writes:
Last year, global data centers used 448 trillion watt-hours of electricity, more than all but 10 countries of the world, said the [United Nations University] report issued Wednesday. That electricity use produced about 208 million tons (189 million metric tons) of carbon dioxide, about the same amount as Argentina, and producing that much energy consumed about 1.2 trillion gallons (4.5 trillion liters) of water, according to the report on the environmental consequences of AI's energy use.
Those numbers, while nearly inconceivable, are projected to increase. Pew Research (Seems, S., Radde, K., 2026) reports that “38% of Americans live within 5 miles of at least one operational data center”, and “another 4% of Americans don’t live near a current operational data center but live within 5 miles of one that’s planned.” A projection made even more upsetting by an analysis done by “a team led by researchers at the University of California at Riverside that estimated by 2028, data centers could contribute to roughly 600,000 asthma cases a year nationwide, and 1,300 premature deaths from the condition” (Smith, 2026). The neglectful implementation of AI and the data centers required to fuel them are causing our communities physical harm.

Data center in Lowell, MA. https://www.commondreams.org/news/data-centers-heat-wave
Aside from environmental and health concerns, job security has become a topic of anxiety across disciplines. The New York Times reports, “Mercor, a startup that sells training data to artificial intelligence companies, pays 30,000 contractors more than $4 million to help make their jobs, and those of their colleagues, obsolete” (Kelley, 2026). The article further illustrates how AI-training start-ups are enthusiastically ushering in a dystopian future in which everyone’s profession essentially involves training and monitoring AI models, quoting one start-up’s founder: “A.I. comes to us, and A.I. learns to run the world” (Kelley, 2026).
Then there is the issue of privacy—a matter close to the heart of every dedicated librarian. Among the many invasions of privacy, law enforcement’s use of AI to illegally track American citizens is one of the most troubling. In an article for ACLU Massachusetts, Epstien (2026) points out, “surveillance technology companies like Axon, Motorola, Flock Safety, and Genetec are rolling out AI-powered predictive policing and ‘real-time crime center’ tools that greatly increase the potential for abuse." They assert that under Trump’s administration, AI companies have been given priority over Americans’ privacy and personal safety, using AI to track license plates and faces to accumulate detailed data on every American’s whereabouts.
Lastly, the poor books. Recent reporting from The Washington Post (Schaffer, A., Oremus, W., Tiku, N., 2026) on Anthropic’s Project Panama, which has involved the literal destruction of millions of books to feed AI models, feels like a metaphor for what the future of AI may have in store for us.
Warehouse of books acquired to train AI. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/01/27/anthropic-ai-scan-destroy-books/The way our current government is allowing AI companies to neglectfully and maliciously enforce the use of AI is unethical and unsustainable for human life. However, like Paulus, I hold a cautious optimism for a possible future with AI. From the many concerns I have already mentioned, though I just barely scratched the surface, it is clear that we are in desperate need of more and better laws around AI in the United States, but I’m hopeful we will get there. Responsible and reasonable people all over the world have been and continue to establish legislation and guidelines to limit the use and reach of AI. Just last month, the American Library Association (ALA) council adopted guidelines for the use of AI in libraries. They assert, “AI may support instruction, operations, accessibility, discovery, or public education when library workers have identified a clear public-service purpose, reviewed benefits and risks, preserved human judgment, and established appropriate safeguards” (ALA, 2026).
Thankfully, we are not alone in this endeavor. There are examples of how libraries in multiple countries have utilized and tested AI’s usefulness in ways that honor both patrons’ and librarians’ humanity. A study done by LibrarIN (2024) focused on the implementation of AI and machine learning (ML) in 13 libraries across Europe and the US Library of Congress. 70 experts from those libraries were interviewed about the incorporation of AI into their libraries. Uses for AI mostly fell into the categories of “automated cataloguing, content tagging, and the digitisation of historical texts” (LibrarIN, 2025). Several of the library experts interviewed reported having a mostly positive experience with the AI and ML tools they used and noted their usefulness. For example, the KB National Library of the Netherlands used AI for the automatic metadating of books. By using AI for this repetitive and tedious task, they were able to decrease their cataloguing backlog and expand public access to their collection (LibrarIN, 2024, p. 37). Despite finding AI tools useful, librarians were not without their concerns, specifically in the areas of “budget constraints, lack of technical expertise, […] ethical concerns surrounding AI-driven decision-making [, and] data privacy” (LibrarIN, 2025). The overall consensus was that AI can be an empowering tool for library professionals and beneficial in helping patrons navigate large collections; however, many library professionals agree it is not a replacement for human intelligence and requires human oversight.
The potential usefulness of AI goes far beyond personal chatbots that rattle off the weather forecast or Google cobbling together answers to our burning questions. There is room for AI to be a helpful, world-expanding tool in multiple disciplines. Whether it becomes the ultimate helper or the ultimate hazard to humanity hinges on our ability to govern it. The thing to remember is that what happens next with AI is within our control. I have hope in the library to navigate these uncertain times with our best interests at the center of its future.
References:
American Library Association. (2026). Guidance on the use of artificial intelligence in libraries. American Library Association. https://www.ala.org/tools/standards-and-guidelines/guidance-use-artificial-intelligence-libraries
Borenstein, S. (2026, June 4). Energy, water use and pollution of AI and data centers rival most countries. PBS News. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/science/energy-water-use-and-pollution-of-ai-and-data-centers-rival-most-countries
Epstein, G. (2026, February 12). Ai-powered surveillance is turning the united states into a digital police state. Now is the t ime to stop it. ACLU Massachusetts. https://www.aclum.org/publications/ai-powered-surveillance-is-turning-the-united- states-into-a-digital-police-state-now-is-the-time-to-stop-it/
Kelley, L. (2026, July 13). The work of helping a.i. destroying work. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/10/business/ai-white-collar-jobs.html
LibrarIN. (2025, February 25). How national libraries are embracing ai for digital transformation. LibrarIN. https://librarin.eu/how-national-libraries-are-embracing-ai-for-digital-transformation/
LibrarIN. (2024). Value co-creation and social innovation for a new generation of European libraries (Reference No. 101061516). LibrarIN. https://librarin.eu/download/21791
Paulus, M. J. (2025). Hope in the library: how libraries can help shape our future with artificial intelligence. Bloomsbury Academic.
Schaffer, A., Oremus, W., Tiku, N. (2026, January 27). Inside an ai start-up’s plan to scan and dispose of millions of books. The Washington Post. https: www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/01/27/anthropic-ai-scan-destroy-books/
Seems, S., Radde, K. ( 2026, April 13). Most new data centers in the U.S. are coming to rural areas. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2026/04/13/most-new-data-centers-in-the-us-are-coming-to-rural-areas/
Smith, F. (2026, January 20). The health divide: The ai data center boom will harm the health of communities that can least afford it. The Center for Health Journalism at USC Anneberg School of Communication and Journalism. https://centerforhealthjournalism.org/our-work/insights/health-divide-ai-data-center-boom-will-harm-health-communities-can-least-afford







Such a thoughtful post, and you have introduced so many of the issues. As you say, we have got to get this under control! We MUST use reason to introduce any AI usage, to help determine, as you say: Whether it becomes the ultimate helper or the ultimate hazard to humanity hinges on our ability to govern it. Reason takes time. AI should never have been introduced without these discussions - without resolving the problem before it happens.
ReplyDelete