The chapter that stood out most to me while reading Hope in the Library was chapter 34: "Finding Oneself in the Library". This chapter stood out to me as someone who worries about his future in the field of librarianship due to the influx of new technologies that seek to replace conventional means of obtaining information. I think we all recognize, at some level, the value that technology and innovation can provide to our overall quality of life as a society. The internet, mobile phones, and social media have undoubtedly played a role in bringing greater access to information to a greater number of people than ever before. However, as people become more and more accustomed to the immediacy and efficiency of new technological advancements in the areas of information acquisition, one can't help but wonder what role a librarian will play in a world when students have ChatGPT in their pocket who can search the entire internet for them at once.
This is why some of the passages of the aforementioned chapter resonated with me. In particular, I felt relieved to read the passage "The university is no longer always certain what it is. But the library remains'. Many cities and universities are still struggling to adapt to the profound social and technological changes wrought by industrial revolutions, especially our most recent one connected with automated information processing" (Paulus, 138). The idea that the library will remain, despite the struggles faced in various sectors including education, gives me a great deal of hope for the future of this career despite the fact that it feels like as a society, we are standing on a constantly shifting foundation. So, with the reassurance that libraries will persist regardless of the ever-developing technology, I got to asking myself: What then, should the library of the future really look like? What is my responsibility to my future students, and to the greater community I will serve?
If I'm completely honest, I believe that AI will never have a place in the field of education. I recognize that may be an unpopular opinion. After all, the Department of Education wrote in a report that AI has the potential to "enable achieving educational priorities in better ways, at scale, and with lower costs" (2023). On the surface, that makes sense. AI can provide information more quickly, enabling less time to be spent on the act of finding the information. However, when one thinks more deeply about that, it seems to me to fly in the face of everything I was taught through my school experience. Anecdotally, one of the most important lessons I learned in school was perseverance in the face of adversity. When something was difficult, I worked hard to overcome the challenge. When I didn't understand the lesson, I reviewed and studied and found new ways to explore the information. When I didn't know where to find the information I needed, I sought out resources that could help direct my search. This process took time. It took dedication to succeed. And, most importantly of all, it took agency on my part. I was responsible for finding the answer, so I was responsible for the sense of achievement I felt when I eventually located it. To take the search out of research, to emphasize quickness of access of information at the expense of a student's effort, is to take the learning out of school. This is something I genuinely believe. Hope in the Library describes the library that I wish to work in during my career, one that is able to "empower people to find meaning and purpose and advance the common good" (Paulus, 137). The key word, I believe, in that passage is "find". When answers are not handed to us, we must seek them. As the old saying goes, it's the journey and not the destination that matters. It's how students get the answers that matters, not the fact that they found the answer. And more often than not, my experience has been that students use AI tools like ChatGPT to simply hand them answers, not to explain difficult concepts to them. I clearly remember one of my high school English students who turned in a book report that they had ChatGPT write for them, on a book that they hadn't acutally read, then tell me I should accept the assignment because "the answers are right, so who cares?". This is the message that I believe schools are sending by encouraging the use of AI in schools.
All of this is also to ignore the other negative impacts AI is having on the world. According to the United Nations, "AI-related water consumption could equal the basic annual domestic needs of 1.3 billion people by the end of the decade, while its land footprint may exceed 14,500 square kilometres — roughly twice the size of the Jakarta metropolitan area". Also, "one widely used AI service is estimated to process around 2.5 billion prompts per day, consuming hundreds of gigawatt-hours of electricity each year" (2026). These are serious concerns that schools are simply ignoring when they choose to use AI tools in their education process. Furthermore, with more and more people becoming afraid that AI replacing their jobs, even the ALA recognizes that "If AI becomes a serious threat to jobs, libraries’ roles in workforce development may become even more important, but also more complicated. A compounded challenge may arise where workforce development will need to encompass not only the preparation for entry level individuals (into a market that is increasingly limited and competitive), but also solutions for a new vacuum in middle level management caused by the elimination of once plentiful entry level workers who matriculated into middle management" (2019). Finally, a metanalysis of articles about AI found that " Biased algorithms can also perpetuate problematic social values. For example, it is recognized that AI-driven language translation tools routinely introduce gender stereotypes when translating from gender-neutral languages, thereby influencing language learners’ social perceptions regarding gender" (Wang, et al, 2024). When one considers all of these issues, it is clear that more work needs to be done to make AI suitable to use on a grand scale.
If anything, I believe a librarian's job in the future should be to educate young people on the dangers of AI, and the research being done to improve it. After all, if AI is ever going to have a place in education, it is going to be up to the students we teach to help make it so. Therefore, the role of the library as I see it is to educate teachers and students about AI: its dangers, its shortcomings, as well as its strengths and possible benefits. We must lead those who wish to learn down the way that will result in the longest overall benefit to their intellectual and creative well-being, not necessarily jump on board the latest trends in order to produce the easiest access to unverified facts.
References
“1 Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Teaching and Learning.” US Department of Education, United States government, May 2023, www.ed.gov/sites/ed/files/documents/ai-report/ai-report.pdf.
“Ai’s Environmental Costs Threaten Water, Land and Climate | UN News.” United Nations, United Nations, 4 June 2026, news.un.org/en/story/2026/06/1167658.
"Artificial Intelligence", American Library Association, February 4, 2019 https://www.ala.org/future/trends/artificialintelligence (Accessed July 31, 2026) Document ID: 46e8a305-3041-4ddf-9aa1-16093ed9325d
Paulus, Michael J. Hope in the Library: How Libraries Can Help Shape Our Future with Artificial Intelligence. Bloomsbury Academic, 2026.
Shan Wang, Fang Wang, Zhen Zhu, Jingxuan Wang, Tam Tran, Zhao Du, Artificial intelligence in education: A systematic literature review, Expert Systems with Applications, Volume 252, Part A, 2024, 124167, ISSN 0957-4174.
I agree with you. Part of our information literacy lessons should concentrate on AI, without the use of AI! Students will be asked to solve the problems that will arise with this new technology, thus we must teach them how to consider the issues associated therewith!
ReplyDelete