Wednesday, August 5, 2026

Hope in the Library: Imagination

     

Chapter 5: The Emergence of Attention and Imagination drew my attention because it highlights what makes us unique, not only from other creatures but from the learning models we have tried to use as imitations of ourselves.  The chapter helps illustrate that libraries can remain humanistic in the age of AI by continuing to prioritize the development of human attention, reflection, imagination, and critical thinking rather than simply providing access to information. While AI excels at processing, organizing, and generating information quickly, the author argues that what makes humans unique is our ability to assign meaning to information, imagine alternatives, and pursue values and aspirations. That these abilities at one point marked a the shift between ancient humans as animals and the beginnings of our existence as sentient beings. Libraries have long supported these uniquely human abilities by preserving knowledge, encouraging inquiry, and creating spaces for thoughtful engagement.

    From this perspective, the role of libraries extends beyond managing collections or adopting new technologies. Libraries serve as institutions that help people develop information literacy, evaluate the credibility of sources, and reflect on the ideas they encounter. In an era when AI can produce convincing misinformation and personalize content to capture attention, libraries become even more important as trusted guides that teach patrons how to think critically rather than simply accept information at face value.

    Paulus also highlights the danger of the "attention economy," in which AI-powered systems compete for and com-modify human attention alongside various social media and entertainment apps or websites. Libraries offer an alternative to these environments by providing spaces designed for concentration, learning, and intellectual exploration. Quiet reading areas, research assistance, educational programming, and access to diverse viewpoints encourage sustained attention and deeper understanding rather than constant distraction.

    Another humanistic role of libraries is fostering community and shared knowledge. Unlike AI systems, libraries help bring people together through discussions, book clubs, public lectures, makerspaces, and cultural events that encourage dialogue and empathy. Librarians act not only as information professionals but also as educators and mentors who help individuals connect information to their own experiences and values.

    Rather than viewing AI as a replacement for librarians, it should be viewed as a tool that enhances library services, similar to digitized finding aids, while keeping human judgment at the center. AI can improve cataloging, discovery, translation, and routine reference tasks, freeing librarians to focus on personalized instruction, ethical guidance, and helping patrons interpret and evaluate information. In this way, libraries remain humanistic by ensuring that technology supports human endeavors instead of replacing them entirely.

    Ultimately, the passage argues that libraries have always been institutions dedicated to preserving collective knowledge and cultivating thoughtful citizens. In the age of AI, their mission becomes even more significant: to protect and strengthen the human capacities for reflection, creativity, ethical reasoning, and informed decision-making that distinguish people from machines. Paulus states "From the beginning, technology has been entangled with human agency." and that will continue for as long as we do. 

https://www.arl.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/2024.03.29-ai-in-libraries-gen-by-PIXLR-AI-Image-Generator-600x450-1.png 

image generated by PIXLR AI Image Generator, pulled from arl.org

    I believe libraries will be continued to be pushed to take advantage of AI by shareholders, legislators and constituents. Therefore, artificial intelligence should be used as a tool while preserving the human-centered values that have always defined the profession. The chapter argues that what distinguishes humans is not simply intelligence in the form of knowledge recollection but our capacity for reflection, imagination, and overall use of that knowledge. Rather than allowing AI to replace these uniquely human capacities, libraries should ensure that technology strengthens them. Libraries have long served as trusted institutions that promote intellectual freedom, equitable access to information, and lifelong learning. In the age of AI, these responsibilities become even more important.

    One of the most significant roles libraries should assume is promoting AI literacy alongside information literacy. Just as librarians teach patrons how to evaluate books, websites, and scholarly sources, they should also teach users how to critically evaluate AI-generated content. Leo S. Lo explains that, "The readiness gap in AI adoption uncovered by the study suggests a disconnect between understanding the potential of AI and the ability to harness it effectively." This reinforces the idea that libraries should not only provide AI technologies but also educate communities on their strengths, limitations, and ethical implications. By helping patrons recognize bias, misinformation, hallucinations, copyright and privacy concerns, libraries continue their long-standing mission of empowering informed citizens rather than passive consumers of information. 

Libraries should also remain places where human judgment is valued over automated decision-making. While AI can improve cataloging, translation, metadata generation, and discovery services, librarians provide something AI cannot: context, empathy, ethical reasoning, and personalized guidance. The Association of College and Research Libraries (ACRL) emphasizes this balance, stating, "However, AI literacy should not imply an obligation to indiscriminately adopt AI tools for all purposes." Instead, library professionals should critically assess whether AI technologies align with the profession's ethical values and the needs of their communities. This perspective supports using AI to enhance library services while ensuring that human expertise remains central to research assistance, collection development, and information instruction.

Finally, libraries should help preserve human agency in research and learning. The chapter warns that AI-driven technologies compete for human attention and can diminish reflection, imagination, and independent thinking. This concern is echoed by recent scholarship on AI in libraries. In The Journal of Academic Librarianship, McCrary argues that "To ensure that AI enhances rather than replaces critical thinking, academic libraries must champion transparency, preserve choice in research methods, provide comprehensive AI literacy instruction, and maintain institutional accountability through ongoing assessment." Rather than encouraging dependence on AI, libraries should teach patrons when AI is appropriate, when traditional research methods are preferable, and how to integrate both responsibly. This approach ensures that users remain active participants in the learning process instead of becoming overly reliant on automated systems.

Overall, I believe libraries should embrace AI without abandoning the humanistic mission described in the chapter. Technology should be viewed as a means of extending access to knowledge rather than replacing the reflective attention that defines humanity. By promoting AI literacy, preserving ethical decision-making, and encouraging critical thinking, libraries can continue to cultivate informed, creative, and engaged communities. As AI continues to evolve, libraries have an opportunity not only to help people use these tools effectively but also to remind society that wisdom, empathy, and imagination remain distinctly human qualities that no algorithm can fully replicate. 

 

 

AI competencies for Academic Library Workers. American Library Association. (n.d.). https://www.ala.org/acrl/standards/ai?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Evolving AI strategies in libraries: Insights from two polls of ARL member representatives over nine months-report published. Association of Research Libraries. (2025, March 11). https://www.arl.org/news/evolving-ai-strategies-in-libraries-insights-from-two-polls-of-arl-member-representatives-over-nine-months-report-published/

Lo, L. (2024). Evaluating AI Literacy in Academic Libraries: A Survey Study with a Focus on U.S. Employees. College & Research Libraries, 85(5), 635. doi:https://doi.org/10.5860/crl.85.5.635 

McCrary, Q. D. (2026). Are we ghosts in the machine? ai, agency, and the future of libraries. The Journal of Academic Librarianship, 52(1), 103181. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.acalib.2025.103181


Monday, August 3, 2026

Hope in the Library



The chapter that called to me was Chapter 34, specifically one part. When asked about AI being a revolution to reflect/reimagine benefits to all, the writer answers, “If it can be, libraries—still standing tall—will have an important role by broadening our individual and collective experiences, freeing us from narrow visions, and resourcing our realization of greater ends. As archives, they will provide us with sources of hope; as sites of anticipation, they will provide us with signs of hope; and as places of action, they will provide structures that help us realize our hopes. In a library, one may discover and find oneself in—and perhaps even transformed by—a shared and hopeful narrative about the greater purposes that create and sustain such an enduring institution” (Paulus 2026). Libraries give everyone the free will to choose what they learn, what they read, and who they become—without an algorithm determining their path. This passage stood out to me because it made me think of the video we watched earlier about how algorithms are choosing what news we see and our search results. AI is constantly predicting our behavior and trapping us into personalized bubbles. However, the library protects our agency, fosters spontaneous discovery, and reminds us that technology should serve higher purposes, not replace them.

While generative Artificial Intelligence offers exciting capabilities—from streamlining routine search tasks to brainstorming ideas—it also carries subtle risks. As highlighted in The Algorithmic Self (2025) reliance on predictive models continuously shapes human self-concept and narrows individual agency. Joseph’s research states, “Recommendation algorithms, predictive language models, and behavior-monitoring AI capabilities now not only present us with what we might consume but with how we ought to feel, how we ought to think, and even how we ought to self-categorize.” While I appreciate the practical benefits of AI in my daily life, libraries must make sure technology remains a tool instead of a dictator of human thought. I’m pretty sure we’ve all seen how this plays out when we let technology become a dictator. Did anyone else watch the movie Smart House on the Disney channel? Sci-fi stories have been warning us about this for years! Joking aside, libraries remain one of the few places where you can stumble upon a new favorite book purely by chance, protecting our ability to think independently outside the algorithmic bubble. 

While I appreciate how convenient AI can be, I can’t ignore what it’s actually costing our planet. We tend to think of tech as this invisible thing, but running these AI models takes a massive toll on the physical world. Massive data centers consume huge amounts of energy and gulp down millions of gallons of freshwater every day just to keep servers cool. I enjoy creating AI images to match novels, but the environmental cost is eye-opening. As noted in the report The Environmental Cost of Artificial Intelligence: Carbon, Water, and Land Footprints (2026), “the energy required to generate a typical AI image is enough to power a 10-watt LED bulb for 17 minutes, and the energy required for a high-complexity AI video is sufficient to run that same bulb for 42 hours. Similarly, the electricity associated water footprint is about two tablespoons (29 mL) for a single image, but jumps to 4.1 liters for a complex video—almost equivalent to a two-day drinking water need for one person.” Chapter 34 talks about signs of hope, but the hope for our future has to include taking care of the environment. As librarians, we have to look at tech ethics. The American Library Association’s Guidance on the Use of Artificial Intelligence in Libraries urges institutions to prioritize environmental sustainability and the public good. To me, that means libraries should ask the hard questions about what technology costs our natural world. 

Imagining library futures using AI and machine learning - Hanging Together

Looking at both the algorithmic bubbles and the heavy environmental toll, it’s clear to me that basic information literacy isn’t enough anymore. In Beyond Information Literacy, Nicole Murph argues that libraries need to focus on critical AI literacy. To me, that means librarians will need to teach patrons to question how algorithms steer our thinking while also recognizing the real water and energy consumed behind every click. Libraries will need to help communities make conscious, thoughtful choices so that humans have free will instead of having our choices made for us. That’s what ‘finding oneself’ in a library is really all about in the age of AI.

References

American Library Association. (2024). Ala.Org. https://www.ala.org/tools/standards-and-guidelines/guidance- use-artificial-intelligence-libraries

Joseph, J. (2025). The algorithmic self: how AI is reshaping human identity, introspection, and agency. Frontiers in Psychology, 16. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1645795

Murph, N. (2025). Beyond Information Literacy: Exploring AI’s Impact on Labor in Academic Libraries. Digital Commons at Loyola Marymount University and Loyola Law School. https://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/librarian_pubs/159/

Pariser, E. (2011). Beware online “filter bubbles”. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8ofWFx525s

Paulus, M. J. J. (2026). Hope in the Library.

The Environmental Cost of Artificial Intelligence: Carbon, Water, and Land Footprints. (2026). In United Nations University. https://unu.edu/inweh/collection/environmental-cost-of-AIs-Enrgy-Use-Carbon-water-and-land-footprints


Sunday, August 2, 2026

Hope in the Library

 As emerging technology continues to reshape how information is created, organized, and retrieved, librarians might find themselves at a crossroads with AI. In Rubin Chapter 4, we see how technological waves have transformed a librarian's work from card catalogs to integrated library systems. When put into context with Michael J. Paulus Jr.'s Hope in the Library, we are challenged to consider how libraries can remain human centered and value driven institutions in this new age of AI.


Chapter 24 "The Postdigital Library" stood out most vividly to me as a compelling view of our current moment. We are called to imagine what we will be when we become post-digital. The way "print books became books, electric lights became lights, digital computers became computers, and so on" (Paulus, 2026). I personally am still grappling with AI, its purposes, its pros and cons, and its impact on the world. This book gave me an invaluable perspective on how the digital and physical have already merged in the library. The primary focus of technology in the library should not be to replace the physical space or human insight and judgement. The new technology in the library should foster human agency in an integrated landscape.

In the beginning of the book, Paulus states that libraries have always been defined by three characteristics: culture, collection, and community. Moving forward, these words help focus our humanistic approach. Libraries can embrace automation and new technology by elevating human thought, not replacing it. Librarians exploring new technology can ask themselves how it will impact the library's culture, community, and collection.

Personally, I try to avoid using AI as much as I can. Every tool, website, and app I use are making it more and more difficulty to opt out of it. My school district recently banned the use of the website TeachersPayTeachers but then held an in-service on how to make your own resources using AI; my eyes are still recovering from rolling so far back in my head. I am currently struggling to write this because I can see how automation and AI search engines can transform a catalog and collection, but I also fear the overuse of AI. This is why I hardly ever come down with an absolute ban.

The NIH did a study in 2025 that found that the use of AI in education has benefits of personalized learning and improved communication. The downsides are the predictable overuse leading to "brain drain" for learners, along with a larger scale concern for digital privacy (Klimova & Pikhart, 2025). I think that students are so interested in AI and new technology that they should be shown how to safely and ethically use it within reason.

Generative AI and Libraries: Claiming Our Place in the Center of a Shared Future explores AI integration in libraries and addresses my concerns about. Hanegan and Rosser introduce the STACKS framework: Strategy, Tactics, Assembly, Curation, Knowledge, and Solutions to implement AI into the library curriculum (2025). Libraries are uniquely positioned to educate and guide our future generation in how to use technology for good.



Personally, I am struggling with embracing AI for various reasons. Current educators are grappling with the same challenge (Ayinde, Ebiefung, & Oladokun, 2026). The environmental impacts alone make me want to cry when I see those AI flyers everywhere. The ethical ramifications, the privacy violations, convincing deep fakes, misinformation... all of those things terrify me. Professionally, I have to wonder if libraries can be the pebble that sends a ripple through the pond or the butterfly's wings that cause a tornado. Paulus did a wonderful thing with his book which was to offer hope.

"To participate in the creation or curation of a library requires faith--faith in the future, faith in human agency, and faith that people will desire and create a better world." -Dr. Michael J. Paulus 2026


References:

Ayinde, Lateef, Ebiefung, Raphael, & Oladokun, Bolaji David. (2026). Adoption of artificial intelligence in academic libraries: A systematic review of current practices, challenges, and research opportunities https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0099133325001818

Hanegan, M., & Rosser, C. (2025). Generative AI and libraries: Claiming our place in the center of a shared future. ALA Editions in collaboration with Core

Klimova, B., & Pikhart, M. (2025). Exploring the effects of artificial intelligence on student and academic well-being in higher education: a mini-review. Frontiers in psychology, 16, 1498132. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1498132

Paulus, M. J., Jr. (2023). Hope in the library: How libraries can help shape our future with artificial intelligence. ALA Editions.

Rubin, R. E., & Rubin, R. G. (2020). Foundations of library and information science (5th ed.). ALA Neal-Schuman.

AI In The Library


In chapter 4, "Why Libraries?”, Paulus (2025) provides a cautiously optimistic response to the question, “Do we really even need libraries these days?” (p. 21). That question grabbed my attention. Perhaps people feel the need to ask because the assumption is that with the advancement of AI, society will eventually no longer need libraries. There is certainly no ignoring or doing away with it; AI is not theoretical, it’s here. As Paulus (2025) writes, “AI has become a ubiquitous and general-purpose technology like the steam engine, electricity, and the digital computer” (p. 23). And as a library student, with a growing understanding of just how crucial and beneficial libraries are and have been to society, I wonder why people see AI as a threat to the existence of libraries. Regardless of how advanced technology becomes, society will continue to need trusted stewards and preservationists of our shared culture and, therefore, well-organized and equitable access to it. Paulus (2025) points out, “Not all institutions age well, but the library has proven itself to be not just relevant but crucial for millennia. It is also one of the few highly trusted and valued institutions in our society” (P. 22). While libraries remain a staple in democratic society, that does not mean they can afford to stagnate. Like with the adoption of the internet, libraries will have to adjust and find their equilibrium with AI. And like other advancements in technology before it, AI comes with its own challenges, but those challenges should be met with, as Paulus puts it, “sufficient human responsibility and accountability” (p. 24). He writes:

The Library[…] has [a] unique role and responsibility as intelligent technologies advance. By designing new automated information processes as well as new human information practices, libraries can help shape a good information environment for both natural and artificial information agents—an environment that is aligned with and advances human values and the hopes they inspire (2025, p. 24). 

Librarians and library patrons should take solace in the library’s ability to evolve with the times and remain not just useful but crucial to society. It’s been said that AI is here to stay, but so are libraries, and now is the time to carefully and thoughtfully consider how libraries can continue to assure ethical, responsible, and equitable use and access to resources as we move forward with and, hopefully, not against AI.  


AI and its place in our future cannot be considered without first addressing the data center in the room: is AI ethical? Libraries and librarians serve the good of the public and are widely considered champions of truth and democracy. As it stands, AI is functioning in direct opposition to those fundamental principles. Like with book bans, librarians find themselves caught between a rock and a hard place. On one hand, is it ethical to engage with AI, and, on the other, does rejecting AI inequitably limit patrons’ access to a new technology? 


There is evidence supporting the claim that AI is not only unethical but dangerous. There is no shortage of new articles and studies revealing the harm AI is causing to the environment, employment, our privacy, and to books. In a PBS article covering the pollution caused by AI and data centers, Borenstein (2026) writes: 

Last year, global data centers used 448 trillion watt-hours of electricity, more than all but 10 countries of the world, said the [United Nations University] report issued Wednesday. That electricity use produced about 208 million tons (189 million metric tons) of carbon dioxide, about the same amount as Argentina, and producing that much energy consumed about 1.2 trillion gallons (4.5 trillion liters) of water, according to the report on the environmental consequences of AI's energy use. 



Image by ChatGPT with prompt "what does 1.2 trillion gallons of water look like?"



Those numbers, while nearly inconceivable, are projected to increase. Pew Research (Seems, S., Radde, K., 2026) reports that “38% of Americans live within 5 miles of at least one operational data center”, and “another 4% of Americans don’t live near a current operational data center but live within 5 miles of one that’s planned.” A projection made even more upsetting by an analysis done by “a team led by researchers at the University of California at Riverside that estimated by 2028, data centers could contribute to roughly 600,000 asthma cases a year nationwide, and 1,300 premature deaths from the condition” (Smith, 2026). The neglectful implementation of AI and the data centers required to fuel them are causing our communities physical harm. 



Data center in Lowell, MA. https://www.commondreams.org/news/data-centers-heat-wave



https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2026/04/13/most-new-data-centers-in-the-us-are-coming-to-rural-areas/



Aside from environmental and health concerns, job security has become a topic of anxiety across disciplines. The New York Times reports, “Mercor, a startup that sells training data to artificial intelligence companies, pays 30,000 contractors more than $4 million to help make their jobs, and those of their colleagues, obsolete” (Kelley, 2026). The article further illustrates how AI-training start-ups are enthusiastically ushering in a dystopian future in which everyone’s profession essentially involves training and monitoring AI models, quoting one start-up’s founder: “A.I. comes to us, and A.I. learns to run the world” (Kelley, 2026).




https://dailyastorian.com/2024/04/25/editorial-cartoon-ai-replacement/




Then there is the issue of privacy—a matter close to the heart of every dedicated librarian. Among the many invasions of privacy, law enforcement’s use of AI to illegally track American citizens is one of the most troubling. In an article for ACLU Massachusetts, Epstien (2026) points out, “surveillance technology companies like Axon, Motorola, Flock Safety, and Genetec are rolling out AI-powered predictive policing and ‘real-time crime center’ tools that greatly increase the potential for abuse." They assert that under Trump’s administration, AI companies have been given priority over Americans’ privacy and personal safety, using AI to track license plates and faces to accumulate detailed data on every American’s whereabouts. 




Lastly, the poor books. Recent reporting from The Washington Post (Schaffer, A., Oremus, W., Tiku, N., 2026) on Anthropic’s Project Panama, which has involved the literal destruction of millions of books to feed AI models, feels like a metaphor for what the future of AI may have in store for us. 

Warehouse of books acquired to train AI. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/01/27/anthropic-ai-scan-destroy-books/




KB National Library of the Netherlands  https://www.cenl.org/library/koninklijke-bibliotheek/


The way our current government is allowing AI companies to neglectfully and maliciously enforce the use of AI is unethical and unsustainable for human life. However, like Paulus, I hold a cautious optimism for a possible future with AI. From the many concerns I have already mentioned, though I just barely scratched the surface, it is clear that we are in desperate need of more and better laws around AI in the United States, but I’m hopeful we will get there. Responsible and reasonable people all over the world have been and continue to establish legislation and guidelines to limit the use and reach of AI. Just last month, the American Library Association (ALA) council adopted guidelines for the use of AI in libraries. They assert, “AI may support instruction, operations, accessibility, discovery, or public education when library workers have identified a clear public-service purpose, reviewed benefits and risks, preserved human judgment, and established appropriate safeguards” (ALA, 2026). 

Thankfully, we are not alone in this endeavor. There are examples of how libraries in multiple countries have utilized and tested AI’s usefulness in ways that honor both patrons’ and librarians’ humanity. A study done by LibrarIN (2024) focused on the implementation of AI and machine learning (ML) in 13 libraries across Europe and the US Library of Congress. 70 experts from those libraries were interviewed about the incorporation of AI into their libraries. Uses for AI mostly fell into the categories of “automated cataloguing, content tagging, and the digitisation of historical texts” (LibrarIN, 2025). Several of the library experts interviewed reported having a mostly positive experience with the AI and ML tools they used and noted their usefulness. For example, the KB National Library of the Netherlands used AI for the automatic metadating of books. By using AI for this repetitive and tedious task, they were able to decrease their cataloguing backlog and expand public access to their collection (LibrarIN, 2024, p. 37). Despite finding AI tools useful, librarians were not without their concerns, specifically in the areas of “budget constraints, lack of technical expertise, […] ethical concerns surrounding AI-driven decision-making [, and] data privacy” (LibrarIN, 2025). The overall consensus was that AI can be an empowering tool for library professionals and beneficial in helping patrons navigate large collections; however, many library professionals agree it is not a replacement for human intelligence and requires human oversight. 


The potential usefulness of AI goes far beyond personal chatbots that rattle off the weather forecast or Google cobbling together answers to our burning questions. There is room for AI to be a helpful, world-expanding tool in multiple disciplines. Whether it becomes the ultimate helper or the ultimate hazard to humanity hinges on our ability to govern it. The thing to remember is that what happens next with AI is within our control. I have hope in the library to navigate these uncertain times with our best interests at the center of its future. 



References: 

American Library Association. (2026). Guidance on the use of artificial intelligence in libraries. American Library Association. https://www.ala.org/tools/standards-and-guidelines/guidance-use-artificial-intelligence-libraries


Borenstein, S. (2026, June 4). Energy, water use and pollution of AI and data centers rival most countries. PBS News.            https://www.pbs.org/newshour/science/energy-water-use-and-pollution-of-ai-and-data-centers-rival-most-countries 


Epstein, G. (2026, February 12). Ai-powered surveillance is turning the united states into a digital police state. Now is the t   ime to stop it. ACLU Massachusetts. https://www.aclum.org/publications/ai-powered-surveillance-is-turning-the-united-       states-into-a-digital-police-state-now-is-the-time-to-stop-it/


Kelley, L. (2026, July 13). The work of helping a.i. destroying work. The New York Times.                                             https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/10/business/ai-white-collar-jobs.html


LibrarIN. (2025, February 25). How national libraries are embracing ai for digital transformation. LibrarIN. https://librarin.eu/how-national-libraries-are-embracing-ai-for-digital-transformation/


LibrarIN. (2024). Value co-creation and social innovation for a new generation of European libraries (Reference No. 101061516). LibrarIN. https://librarin.eu/download/21791


Paulus, M. J. (2025). Hope in the library: how libraries can help shape our future with artificial intelligence. Bloomsbury Academic.


Schaffer, A., Oremus, W., Tiku, N. (2026, January 27). Inside an ai start-up’s plan to scan and dispose of millions of books. The Washington Post. https: www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/01/27/anthropic-ai-scan-destroy-books/


Seems, S., Radde, K. ( 2026, April 13). Most new data centers in the U.S. are coming to rural areas. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2026/04/13/most-new-data-centers-in-the-us-are-coming-to-rural-areas/


Smith, F. (2026, January 20). The health divide: The ai data center boom will harm the health of communities that can least afford it. The Center for Health Journalism at USC Anneberg School of Communication and Journalism. https://centerforhealthjournalism.org/our-work/insights/health-divide-ai-data-center-boom-will-harm-health-communities-can-least-afford

Saturday, August 1, 2026

Keeping Humanity at the Center of AI

Technologies are rapidly changing, often faster than people can keep pace with. Artificial intelligence has been around longer than many people realize; however, in recent years the capabilities of AI have expanded greatly. AI and machine learning affect many parts of our day-to-day life. Some fear AI and its future potential, while others are fascinated to ponder the possibilities of the future. Michael J. Paulus, Jr., author of the book Hope in the Library: How Libraries Can Help Shape Our Future with Artificial Intelligence, explores how the library can both welcome AI and its capabilities while also still fulfilling their core missions: to preserve knowledge, to serve people, and to provide equitable access.

                                                                        Figure 1
                                            AI-generated illustration of a robot working in a library.

    The chapter from this book that most called to my heart was Chapter 5, “The Emergence of Attention and Imagination” In the opening of this chapter, Paulus explained that the earliest life forms survived by automatically reacting to environmental factors. Paulus then goes on to explain what Yuval Harari calls the “Tree of Knowledge mutation” (p.27). The argument made here is that humans are distinguished not only by their intelligence, but also by their ability to reflect, imagine, and hope. Later, he reminds readers that technology has always shaped human experiences. Early technology—weaponry, stone tools, and fire—changed the development of humanity. He writes, “From the beginning technology has been entangled with human agency” (p.28). In other words, one cannot evolve without the other.

Figure 2
AI-generated artwork illustrating creativity and artificial intelligence.

    Undoubtedly, AI is rapidly changing the face of education. This chapter resonated with me because it challenged the idea libraries must either embrace AI and technology, or they must strive to preserve the more traditional library values. Instead, libraries should embrace both. As a school librarian, it will be my job to still foster curiosity, critical thinking, and creativity, while also preparing users to navigate and wisely use ever-changing digital information.

    As we move into the future, it is important to note that AI literacy cannot exist apart from humans. Hanegan & Rosser (2025, p.97) note:

AI literacy doesn’t emerge in isolation; it exists within a complex system of multiple literacies that librarians have been mapping and exploring for decades. Across the library universe, professionals chart diverse constellations of literacies— information, digital, media, visual, and more. At the core of this system are durable skills like critical thinking, information discovery, and ethical reasoning. These skills form the gravitational center around which AI literacy revolves.

This connects to Chapter 5 because Paulus, Jr. observes that intelligence is not just what makes mankind unique. Also, our attention and ability to reflect and imagine make humans unique. As AI can help users get information more quickly and automatically than ever before, libraries, especially school libraries, must teach users to slow down, pay close attention to information being given, reflect and think critically about the information. Most importantly, we must encourage our students to imagine future possibilities.

Figure 3
AI Literacy: The Four Key Concepts of AI Literacy That Everyone Needs to Know.

    Throughout history, as new innovations have evolved, there have always been ethical questions. It is the same with AI, and libraries have an important role in this discussion.  In the IFLA’s statement on Libraries and Artificial Intelligence, it states, “By helping their patrons understand AI, libraries could also enable them to participate in policy discussions on what it means for AI to be used ‘for good’, and which use cases are ethical and desirable for the public” (2020, p.2).

    Finally, libraries must always keep our users at the center of our focus. Garcia-Febo (2019), an international library consultant, best sums up the issue when she writes, “My fellow library workers, the future of libraries will continue to be about the communities we serve. Librarians and library professionals will need to be at the forefront to support communities as these technologies transform our world. Let’s continue the conversation and learn together.”

    Throughout our course, we have learned that libraries have adapted to changes. AI is just latest change of the library’s long history. While many may try to argue that AI can and will replace libraries, it is imperative to remember that AI cannot exist apart from humans. AI is another tool that if used correctly can enhance student learning. School libraries have the role of incorporating traditional library values and technologies like AI into student learning.

 

Figure 4
Librarian teaching AI literacy to students.

 

Sources:

Garcia-Febo, L. (2019). Exploring AI. American Libraries, 50(3/4), 4–5. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26612536

Hanegan, M., & Rosser, C. (2025). Generative ai and libraries : Claiming our place in the center of a shared future. American Library Association.

International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions. (2020, October). IFLA statement on libraries and artificial intelligence. https://repository.ifla.org/rest/api/core/bitstreams/8d21df6c-e61b-41a5-b089-0353a5552dbd/content

Paulus, M. J., Jr. (2026). Hope in the library: How libraries can help shape our future with artificial intelligence. Bloomsbury Academic.


Images sources 

Figure 1 - Tanzi, N. (2023, December 28). Library tech trends for 2024 [AI-generated image]. The Digital Librarian. https://the-digital-librarian.com/2023/12/28/library-tech-trends-for-2024/

Figure 2 - Basha, M. (2024, September 9). Unlocking creativity: The power of AI prompts in art and design [AI-generated image]. Medium. https://mahaboob.medium.com/unlocking-creativity-the-power-of-ai-prompts-in-art-and-design-f3bb802f525e

Figure 3 - Anders, B. A. (2025). AI literacy: The four key concepts of AI literacy that everyone needs to know [Infographic]. Sovorel Center for Teaching & Learning. https://sovorelpublishing.com/index.php/infographics

Figure 4 - Tanzi, N. (2025, May 27). How public libraries can support youth in the age of AI [AI-generated illustration]. The Digital Librarian. https://the-digital-librarian.com/2025/05/27/how-public-libraries-can-support-youth-in-the-age-of-ai/

  

Finding Oneself in the Library

The chapter that stood out most to me while reading Hope in the Library was chapter 34: "Finding Oneself in the Library".  This chapter stood out to me as someone who worries about his future in the field of librarianship due to the influx of new technologies that seek to replace conventional means of obtaining information.  I think we all recognize, at some level, the value that technology and innovation can provide to our overall quality of life as a society.  The internet, mobile phones, and social media have undoubtedly played a role in bringing greater access to information to a greater number of people than ever before.  However, as people become more and more accustomed to the immediacy and efficiency of new technological advancements in the areas of information acquisition, one can't help but wonder what role a librarian will play in a world when students have ChatGPT in their pocket who can search the entire internet for them at once.

This is why some of the passages of the aforementioned chapter resonated with me.  In particular, I felt relieved to read the passage "The university is no longer always certain what it is.  But the library remains'.  Many cities and universities are still struggling to adapt to the profound social and technological changes wrought by industrial revolutions, especially our most recent one connected with automated information processing" (Paulus, 138).  The idea that the library will remain, despite the struggles faced in various sectors including education, gives me a great deal of hope for the future of this career despite the fact that it feels like as a society, we are standing on a constantly shifting foundation.  So, with the reassurance that libraries will persist regardless of the ever-developing technology, I got to asking myself: What then, should the library of the future really look like?  What is my responsibility to my future students, and to the greater community I will serve?


If I'm completely honest, I believe that AI will never have a place in the field of education.  I recognize that may be an unpopular opinion.  After all, the Department of Education wrote in a report that AI has the potential to "enable achieving educational priorities in better ways, at scale, and with lower costs" (2023).  On the surface, that makes sense.  AI can provide information more quickly, enabling less time to be spent on the act of finding the information.  However, when one thinks more deeply about that, it seems to me to fly in the face of everything I was taught through my school experience.  Anecdotally, one of the most important lessons I learned in school was perseverance in the face of adversity.  When something was difficult, I worked hard to overcome the challenge.  When I didn't understand the lesson, I reviewed and studied and found new ways to explore the information.  When I didn't know where to find the information I needed, I sought out resources that could help direct my search.  This process took time.  It took dedication to succeed.  And, most importantly of all, it took agency on my part.  I was responsible for finding the answer, so I was responsible for the sense of achievement I felt when I eventually located it.  To take the search out of research, to emphasize quickness of access of information at the expense of a student's effort, is to take the learning out of school.  This is something I genuinely believe.  Hope in the Library describes the library that I wish to work in during my career, one that is able to "empower people to find meaning and purpose and advance the common good" (Paulus, 137).  The key word, I believe, in that passage is "find".  When answers are not handed to us, we must seek them.  As the old saying goes, it's the journey and not the destination that matters.  It's how students get the answers that matters, not the fact that they found the answer.  And more often than not, my experience has been that students use AI tools like ChatGPT to simply hand them answers, not to explain difficult concepts to them.  I clearly remember one of my high school English students who turned in a book report that they had ChatGPT write for them, on a book that they hadn't acutally read, then tell me I should accept the assignment because "the answers are right, so who cares?".  This is the message that I believe schools are sending by encouraging the use of AI in schools.

All of this is also to ignore the other negative impacts AI is having on the world.  According to the United Nations, "AI-related water consumption could equal the basic annual domestic needs of 1.3 billion people by the end of the decade, while its land footprint may exceed 14,500 square kilometres — roughly twice the size of the Jakarta metropolitan area".  Also, "one widely used AI service is estimated to process around 2.5 billion prompts per day, consuming hundreds of gigawatt-hours of electricity each year" (2026).  These are serious concerns that schools are simply ignoring when they choose to use AI tools in their education process.  Furthermore, with more and more people becoming afraid that AI replacing their jobs, even the ALA recognizes that "If AI becomes a serious threat to jobs, libraries’ roles in workforce development may become even more important, but also more complicated. A compounded challenge may arise where workforce development will need to encompass not only the preparation for entry level individuals (into a market that is increasingly limited and competitive), but also solutions for a new vacuum in middle level management caused by the elimination of once plentiful entry level workers who matriculated into middle management" (2019). Finally, a metanalysis of articles about AI found that " Biased algorithms can also perpetuate problematic social values. For example, it is recognized that AI-driven language translation tools routinely introduce gender stereotypes when translating from gender-neutral languages, thereby influencing language learners’ social perceptions regarding gender" (Wang, et al, 2024).  When one considers all of these issues, it is clear that more work needs to be done to make AI suitable to use on a grand scale.

If anything, I believe a librarian's job in the future should be to educate young people on the dangers of AI, and the research being done to improve it.  After all, if AI is ever going to have a place in education, it is going to be up to the students we teach to help make it so.  Therefore, the role of the library as I see it is to educate teachers and students about AI: its dangers, its shortcomings, as well as its strengths and possible benefits.  We must lead those who wish to learn down the way that will result in the longest overall benefit to their intellectual and creative well-being, not necessarily jump on board the latest trends in order to produce the easiest access to unverified facts.



References

“1 Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Teaching and Learning.” US Department of Education,               United States government, May 2023, www.ed.gov/sites/ed/files/documents/ai-report/ai-report.pdf. 

“Ai’s Environmental Costs Threaten Water, Land and Climate | UN News.” United Nations, United                 Nations, 4 June 2026, news.un.org/en/story/2026/06/1167658. 

"Artificial Intelligence", American Library Association, February 4, 2019 https://www.ala.org/future/trends/artificialintelligence (Accessed July 31, 2026) Document ID: 46e8a305-3041-4ddf-9aa1-16093ed9325d

Paulus, Michael J. Hope in the Library: How Libraries Can Help Shape Our Future with Artificial Intelligence. Bloomsbury Academic, 2026.

 Shan Wang, Fang Wang, Zhen Zhu, Jingxuan Wang, Tam Tran, Zhao Du, Artificial intelligence in                    education: A systematic literature review, Expert Systems with Applications, Volume 252, Part                A, 2024, 124167, ISSN 0957-4174.