Sunday, August 2, 2026

Hope in the Library

 As emerging technology continues to reshape how information is created, organized, and retrieved, librarians might find themselves at a crossroads with AI. In Rubin Chapter 4, we see how technological waves have transformed a librarian's work from card catalogs to integrated library systems. When put into context with Michael J. Paulus Jr.'s Hope in the Library, we are challenged to consider how libraries can remain human centered and value driven institutions in this new age of AI.


Chapter 24 "The Postdigital Library" stood out most vividly to me as a compelling view of our current moment. We are called to imagine what we will be when we become post-digital. The way "print books became books, electric lights became lights, digital computers became computers, and so on" (Paulus, 2026). I personally am still grappling with AI, its purposes, its pros and cons, and its impact on the world. This book gave me an invaluable perspective on how the digital and physical have already merged in the library. The primary focus of technology in the library should not be to replace the physical space or human insight and judgement. The new technology in the library should foster human agency in an integrated landscape.

In the beginning of the book, Paulus states that libraries have always been defined by three characteristics: culture, collection, and community. Moving forward, these words help focus our humanistic approach. Libraries can embrace automation and new technology by elevating human thought, not replacing it. Librarians exploring new technology can ask themselves how it will impact the library's culture, community, and collection.

Personally, I try to avoid using AI as much as I can. Every tool, website, and app I use are making it more and more difficulty to opt out of it. My school district recently banned the use of the website TeachersPayTeachers but then held an in-service on how to make your own resources using AI; my eyes are still recovering from rolling so far back in my head. I am currently struggling to write this because I can see how automation and AI search engines can transform a catalog and collection, but I also fear the overuse of AI. This is why I hardly ever come down with an absolute ban.

The NIH did a study in 2025 that found that the use of AI in education has benefits of personalized learning and improved communication. The downsides are the predictable overuse leading to "brain drain" for learners, along with a larger scale concern for digital privacy (Klimova & Pikhart, 2025). I think that students are so interested in AI and new technology that they should be shown how to safely and ethically use it within reason.

Generative AI and Libraries: Claiming Our Place in the Center of a Shared Future explores AI integration in libraries and addresses my concerns about. Hanegan and Rosser introduce the STACKS framework: Strategy, Tactics, Assembly, Curation, Knowledge, and Solutions to implement AI into the library curriculum (2025). Libraries are uniquely positioned to educate and guide our future generation in how to use technology for good.



Personally, I am struggling with embracing AI for various reasons. Current educators are grappling with the same challenge (Ayinde, Ebiefung, & Oladokun, 2026). The environmental impacts alone make me want to cry when I see those AI flyers everywhere. The ethical ramifications, the privacy violations, convincing deep fakes, misinformation... all of those things terrify me. Professionally, I have to wonder if libraries can be the pebble that sends a ripple through the pond or the butterfly's wings that cause a tornado. Paulus did a wonderful thing with his book which was to offer hope.

"To participate in the creation or curation of a library requires faith--faith in the future, faith in human agency, and faith that people will desire and create a better world." -Dr. Michael J. Paulus 2026


References:

Ayinde, Lateef, Ebiefung, Raphael, & Oladokun, Bolaji David. (2026). Adoption of artificial intelligence in academic libraries: A systematic review of current practices, challenges, and research opportunities https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0099133325001818

Hanegan, M., & Rosser, C. (2025). Generative AI and libraries: Claiming our place in the center of a shared future. ALA Editions in collaboration with Core

Klimova, B., & Pikhart, M. (2025). Exploring the effects of artificial intelligence on student and academic well-being in higher education: a mini-review. Frontiers in psychology, 16, 1498132. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1498132

Paulus, M. J., Jr. (2023). Hope in the library: How libraries can help shape our future with artificial intelligence. ALA Editions.

Rubin, R. E., & Rubin, R. G. (2020). Foundations of library and information science (5th ed.). ALA Neal-Schuman.

1 comment:

  1. I hear you. It seems decisions are all based in politics anymore, NOT reason. As crucial as these problems are becoming, we MUST use reason to solve them, NOT popularity! I think our youth must be guided, in order to prevent “brain drain.” As with all animals, we gravitate toward the easiest way, but we MUST pull our students toward the hard, yet engaging way, for their own good!

    ReplyDelete