Libraries and technology are two of our most valuable resources as humans. While technology is changing faster than we could ever dream of, libraries persist. In the book Hope in the Library: How libraries can help shape our future with artificial intelligence, chapter 4, called "Why Libraries?" stood out to me regarding how libraries can stay humanistic in the age of AI. Author Michael J. Paulus Jr. states that "not all institutions age well, but the library has proven itself to be not just relevant but crucial for millennia" (Paulus, 2026, p. 22). To me, it's grounding to think of working in an institution that has been around for almost 5,000 years, when compared to computer technology which is less than 100 years old. This chapter also stood out as not condemning the advancement of technology, but emphasizing the library's "unique role and responsibility" in that advancement (Paulus, 2026, p. 24). I think many want to pit the institutions of the library and technology against each other, and encourage the idea that one becomes obsolete as the other grows, but why have we convinced ourselves that they can't work together? With AI specifically, I will admit that I personally have a very strong anti-AI stance, particularly when it comes to generative AI. But I'm also realistic and know that it's not something that can be totally avoided. So I was hopeful when I read the quote, "AI systems... need to be designed to advance- and their autonomy should be governed by- human values and goals" (Paulus, 2026, p. 23). This idea that we don't have to fight or completely give in to the so-called "inevitability" of AI use, but fight for the systems to work with "human values and goals" in mind filled me with a lot of hope.
The work of a librarian has always "intersected with technology, and this intersection has material, social, and cultural impacts" (Slater, 2025). I think with technology such as AI, it's very important for librarians to be on the front lines of investigating the potential harms of this new technology, and not just accepting it as inevitable. A 2025 paper conducted a systematic review of literature surrounding libraries and AI usage and found that most of the papers out there focus on the integration of AI use, and few focus on "how academic libraries can support ethical, transparent, and informed use of AI in the creation of scientific knowledge" (Sousa, 2025).
(Sousa, 2025)
Authors in various papers reviewed by Sousa determine that "a human-in-the-loop approach is recommended to maintain quality and accountability," as in, any use of AI intended to completely replace human involvement is not ideal, but using tools that are meant to assist people without doing the work completely for them is (Sousa, 2025). In my AP Research class, I want to teach students how to go through the research process, encouraging critical thinking and reading stamina. There have been several AI tools developed that can simplify and speed up this process, but I don't teach them to my students because then they don't have the foundational tools they need to be successful. Only teaching students how to use AI tools to research without teaching them the foundational skills would be like teaching students to use a calculator but not how to do actual math. Jonathan Crary warns of students and other researchers becoming "ghosts in the machine" as "students increasingly engage with these tools without recognizing how their research processes are being reshaped" (McCrary, 2026).
Overall, it is our responsibility as librarians to assist in providing access to tools in order to gain new information, whether those tools are books, devices, or technology systems. However, this doesn't mean we should blindly embrace AI just because the tech companies have convinced us we'll get "left behind" if we don't use their technology. Like with other types of technology or resources, it's our job to vet them and teach our students (and the community) proper ethical usage.
References
Bradley, F. (2022). Representation of Libraries in Artificial Intelligence Regulations and Implications for Ethics and Practice. Journal of the Australian Library and Information Association, 71(3). https://doi.org/10.1080/24750158.2022.2101911
McCrary, Q.D. (2026). Are we ghosts in the machine? AI, agency, and the future of libraries. The Journal of Academic Librarianship, 52(1), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.acalib.2025.103181
Paulus Jr., M.J. (2026). Hope in the Library: How libraries can help shape our future with artificial intelligence. Bloomsbury Academic.
Slater, K. (2025). Against AI: Critical refusal in the Library. Library Trends 73(4), 588-608. https://dx.doi.org/10.1353/lib.2025.a968497
Sousa, N. (2025). Ethical and Practical Implications of AI in Academic Library Research. IFLA Journal. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/03400352251391753
Thank you for Bradley’s quote. Yes, we need to “think this through.” There is no rush, except for corporate rush and the disintegration of professional roles. Look at what has happened with “free-range” social media. It will be the same for AI! You are so correct to step back, so to speak. Ethical considerations should be #1!
ReplyDelete