Thursday, July 30, 2026

Keeping Libraries Human in the Age of AI: Why Books Still Matter

Technology has always changed the way we interact with information. The printing press changed how books were created and shared, the internet changed how we access information, and now artificial intelligence (AI) is changing how we search for and process knowledge. While these advancements bring exciting possibilities, they also make us ask an important question: How can libraries continue to be human-centered in an increasingly digital world? I believe libraries can remain human-centered by embracing technology thoughtfully while protecting the experiences that have always defined libraries: reading deeply, connecting with others, and developing the ability to think, question, and learn.


Figure 1. Books and AI illustration. Source: Spines.

   After reading Hope in the Library, the chapter that stood out to me the most was Chapter 27, “The Future of the Book.” As someone who spends my days teaching students to love reading, this chapter immediately caught my attention. It highlights something I strongly believe: books are about much more than simply receiving information. Books allow readers to enter new worlds, consider different perspectives, and connect with ideas beyond their own experiences.

Paulus explains that reading a book allows a reader to temporarily step outside their own world while also bringing something new back into it. Unlike AI, which can process and summarize information from a text, human readers interact with books through reflection, emotion, and personal experience. Paulus writes that “deep reading…is a hard-won achievement of humanity” (Paulus, 2026). He argues that losing the ability to engage deeply with complex texts would diminish an important part of what makes us human.

This idea stood out to me because libraries are not just places where people find information. They are places where people discover ideas, build connections, and develop a deeper understanding of themselves and the world around them. Paulus explains that books do not exist as isolated objects; they connect with other books, conversations, and communities. Libraries create these connections between books, readers, and ideas. The “interval between books” created by libraries shapes how people imagine and understand the world (Paulus, 2026).


Figure 2. Students reading in the library. Source: Riverbank Primary School.

I do not believe libraries should avoid AI completely. Instead, I believe libraries should use AI thoughtfully while protecting the human connections that make libraries special. AI can be useful for improving access, assisting with organization, and supporting learning, but it should not replace librarians or the skills that librarians teach.

The American Library Association emphasizes this idea in its guidance for AI use in libraries, stating that “AI will complement rather than replace human intelligence, reasoning, deliberation, and critical thinking” (American Library Association, 2024). This is especially important in school libraries. Students need more than quick answers; they need guidance in evaluating information, asking meaningful questions, and developing their own understanding of the world around them.

The Association of College and Research Libraries (ACRL) also emphasizes human-AI collaboration. Rather than replacing human abilities, AI should be used as a tool that supports creativity, problem-solving, and decision-making (Association of College and Research Libraries, 2024). School librarians have an important role in helping students understand both the benefits and limitations of AI while developing responsible technology habits.


Figure 3. AI and books illustration. Source: Aljeebal.

    One concern with technology is that it can make it easier to consume information quickly without truly engaging with it. Maryanne Wolf, a researcher who studies reading and the brain, explains that technology itself is not the problem, but we must consider how it affects human learning and development. She argues that new technologies should not interfere with the development of skills like empathy, thoughtful decision-making, and the ability to make informed choices (Wolf, 2024).

This connects closely with the role of libraries. For students, especially young readers, libraries provide experiences that go beyond simply finding information. A librarian can help a student discover a book that changes how they see themselves or the world around them. While AI may recommend a title based on previous interests, it cannot replace the conversation, encouragement, and relationship that often inspires a student to become a lifelong reader.

The future of libraries should not be about choosing between books and technology. Libraries have always adapted to new tools while maintaining their purpose: helping people learn, explore, and connect with information. AI can be a valuable resource, but libraries should continue protecting the human experiences that technology cannot replace.


Figure 4. Elementary students in the library. Source: Welton Primary School.

In an age where information is everywhere, librarians may become even more important in helping students become thoughtful readers, responsible technology users, and individuals who can analyze information and make informed decisions. Books and technology will continue to change, but the need for human connection, curiosity, and learning will remain.



References

Aljeebal. (n.d.). AI in hand with book [Illustration]. https://aljeebal.com/posts/3937

American Library Association. (2024). ALA's guidance for the use of artificial intelligence in libraries. https://www.ala.org/tools/standards-and-guidelines/guidance-use-artificial-intelligence-libraries

Association of College and Research Libraries. (2024). Developing an AI literacy framework: A call to action. (Use the exact title from the article.) https://crln.acrl.org/index.php/crlnews/article/view/26704/34626

Paulus, M. J. (2026). The future of the book. In Hope in the Library. (Publisher information.)

Riverbank Primary School. (n.d.). Upper elementary students in library [Photograph]. https://www.riverbankprimary.org/

Spines. (n.d.). AI in publishing industry [Illustration]. https://spines.com/ai-in-publishing-industry/

Welton Primary School. (n.d.). Elementary students in library [Photograph]. https://www.weltonprimaryschool.co.uk/our-curriculum/english.htm

Wolf, M. (2024). Deep reading as a tool for attaining empathy & critical thinking skills. UCLA School of Education and Information Studies. https://seis.ucla.edu/news/maryanne-wolf-deep-reading-a-tool-for-attaining-empathy-critical-thinking-skills/


3 comments:

  1. Emily,
    I agree that libraries can remain human-centered by embracing technology thoughtfully while protecting the experiences that define libraries. I think that as long as we remember and focus on the mission of libraries, then AI could be beneficial instead of harmful.
    I enjoyed reading chapter 27 as well.
    In this ever changing world, AI is upon us and we can choose to embrace it in the best way possible.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love the idea that reading is about the process and not an end-goal. I actually just saw a social media post that said something along the lines of 'some people like generative AI because they think the idea they have is the most important part, and not the work put in to achieve that idea.' I think sometimes we forget that the journey is just as important as the destination, especially when it comes to reading and researching and writing. I teach AP Research at my school, and while I could teach my students how to use AI tools to do some of the work for them, that takes out the hard work that I want them to learn is good for them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As you point out, these must be developed: creativity, problem-solving, and decision-making! They cannot be developed if students are taught to let AI do it for them. The brain will not develop to do so! Thus, we must fight to keep it away from students until they are around 16 or so, in my professional opinion. I am thinking cognitive psychologists would agree. Do you?

    ReplyDelete