Source: Lo, L. S., & Vitale, C. H.
Source: WebJunction
As I read Hope in the Library, the chapter that "called" to me most as regards how libraries can remain humanistic in the age of Artificial Intelligence is Chapter 29 titled, "Library Automation and Intelligence Augmentation." This chapter emphasized that AI should strengthen and enhance the work of librarians instead of replacing librarians. While I don't love AI one hundred percent, I do believe it is sticking around. Since it is sticking around, I think we need to make the most of it. I think it can be a wonderful, helpful tool, if it is used properly and not being abused. I do not feel that AI will replace librarians - what a relief that is. Librarians do so much that AI cannot. Technology cannot replace the humanistic roles that matter so much when working with people. Librarians and educators create personal connections within their community, schools, and classrooms. They help people build social skills and guide people on personal levels. AI can help in many ways, but not in the ways that matter the most.
In Seasholes' video, it talks about how libraries are environments that foster learning and student achievement. The video discusses the many roles of librarians and how they are essential to education. There are so many roles librarians have that AI could never provide. AI should be used, but not depended upon. Paulus shares so many ways throughout his book that discusses how AI should be used in the library. "New technologies are often used, first, to do old things more efficiently." (Paulus, 2026, p. 116). AI should be used to make our lives easier by supplementing how we complete some tasks; it should not be something that is used to completely replace humans' work.
AI can help alleviate some of the hard work librarians do every day, and this will allow librarians more time to put their focus on things that are more important. If AI can complete repetitive tasks that take up librarians' time, then librarians and other professionals can spend more time and focus to serve the needs of the people around them. AI cannot and should not replace the unique aspects that librarians and other professionals carry with them. Paulus stated, "As automation and intelligent technologies improve, there may be additional opportunities to automate more library services currently performed by humans. But this will require proactive and ethical design, as well as ongoing oversight, to ensure that automation enhances and does not inhibit human creativity, relationships, and ambitions." (2026, p. 117). AI does not have the full capability to replace librarians and the amazing work that is done each and every day.
As librarians, we should encourage our patrons to use critical thinking, creativity, and collaboration. Now, that can be assisted by AI. We can encourage our patrons to use AI in a very humanistic way. Two quotes from Paulus that stuck out to me are: "... and they were empowering people to search for, use, and create information in new ways." (2026, p. 117) and, "Through all these changes, libraries demonstrated their understanding that material technologies... need accompanying formative practices to empower human agency." (2026, p. 117). My take away from these quotes is, we can encourage our patrons to use AI, but we also have to teach them not to only depend on the use AI. If AI is being used, additional work needs to be added to it to make it personalized and unique. If AI is depended on totally, that means there is no human agency. Paulus also said, "... information literacy involves identifying information needs and then being able to find, evaluate, and use information to fulfill those needs." (2026, p. 117). No one needs to use AI to replace their work, only as a helpful aide to make things a little easier.
Subaveerapandiyan's article discusses many ways AI has and can transform the work and services happening in libraries. The main highlights mentioned are: information retrieval, discovery, cataloging, classification, references, collection management, digital library management, and some administrative tasks. The article discusses the potential AI has to improve library services. As I mentioned above, the success of using AI depends on if it is used correctly and responsibly. If AI usage is being abused or used incorrectly, then the results will not be as positive.
Marchionini's argument supports that AI should be used to augment rather than replace the work of library professionals. Part of his argument is that librarians have an important role of making sure AI is used correctly and responsibly. He also argues that library professionals already have expertise in the areas AI is useful, so they can ensure AI is incorporated properly. Marchionini stated, "Information and Library Science (ILS) professionals have skills, perspectives, and practices that are essential to human interests in the AI-augmented world. We are especially crucial because of our human-centered approach to information and technology impact. For ILS professionals, human interest is not an add-on or after-thought but rather the reason we do the work at all - it is fundamentally baked into information generation, management, and use." (2024, p. 1). I agree with Marchionini so much, because ILS professionals truly are built for implementing the safe and responsible use of AI. In addition to using it themselves, they have the access to reach many other patrons and teach them to use AI safely and responsibly as well.
In the article, Responsible AI Practice in Libraries and Archives: A Review of the Literature, the authors discuss responsible AI practices. According to Mannheimer et al., "As AI comes into more common usage, it will benefit the library and archives professions to not only consider ethics when implementing local projects, but to publicly discuss these ethical considerations in shared documentation and publications." (2024). If libraries are going to use AI technologies, they do need to consider the ethical concerns as well.
In Blair's article, she discusses that modern libraries are still working to provide free access to information and services, while also striving to adapt to the modern demands of society. If libraries are not up to date to what patrons are needing, they may lose patron's interest, meaning they may not survive the modern demands and be forced to close. Paulus stated, "... many are hopeful that libraries can adopt and adapt AI technologies and literacies to advance their profession's millennia-long history of augmenting human knowledge and intelligence through new information technologies and practices." (2026, p. 118). Since AI is very much sticking around, I think we can make the most of it by modernizing libraries and using AI to advance the amazing work that is already being done. Librarians can find ways to use AI that would support them and their patrons best, all the while still putting their personal touch on the things that happen in the environment.
Source: Robinson, L.
References
Blair, E. (2013, September 1). With modern makeovers, America's libraries are branching out. NPR. https://www.npr.org/2013/09/01/217211315/with-modern-makeovers-americas-libraries-are-branching-out.
Lo, L. S., & Vitale, C. H. (2024). Evolving AI strategies in libraries: Insights from two polls of ARL member representatives over nine months. Association of Research Libraries. https://doi.org/10.29242/report.aipolls2023.
Mannheimer, S., Bond, N., Young, S. W. H., Kettler, H. S., Marcus, A., Slipher, S. K., Clark, J. A., Shorish, Y., Rossmann, D., & Sheehey, B. (2024). Responsible AI Practice in Libraries and Archives: A Review of the Literature. Information Technology and Libraries, 43(3). https://link-gale-com.ezproxy.etsu.edu/apps/doc/A813057595/PROF?u=tel_a_etsul&sid=bookmark-PROF&xid=d19718fb.
Marchionini, G. (2024). Information and library professionals' roles and responsibilities in an AI augmented world. Journal of the Association for Information Science & Technology, 75(8), 865-868. https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.24930.
Paulus, M. J., Jr. (2026). Hope in the library: How libraries can help shape our future with artificial intelligence. Bloomsbury Academic.
Robinson, L. (2024, December 11). AICollaboratory launches HERITAGE–AI initiative with major grant. College of Information, University of Maryland. https://info.umd.edu/news/aicollaboratory-launches-heritage-ai-initiative-with-major-grant/.
Seasholes, C. (2013, January 9). Teacher librarians at the heart of student learning [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_ybY5O7WvA.
Subaveerapandiyan, A. (2023). Application of Artificial Intelligence (AI) In Libraries and Its Impact on Library Operations Review. Library Philosophy and Practice, 1-19. https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/application-artificial-intelligence-ai-libraries/docview/2848495833/se-2.
WebJunction. (2025, August 28). What's on the horizon for AI and public libraries? https://www.webjunction.org/news/webjunction/public-libraries-ai-future.html.
Great blog post! I saw similar opinions from professionals in my research. They all seem to mostly agree that AI can be helpful in slogging through tedious and repetitive tasks, but it requires human oversight and is not a replacement for a human expert.
ReplyDeleteEven though your resources are the best at present, and your argument is most sound, I still believe we are seeing “double talk.” AI will be used for all these things, but we will still be necessary. For what, input? That is not a professional job. We MUST understand all these concepts in order that we can control the services and offerings. Otherwise, AI controls for us. I do not think these “understandings” are at all settled. Thoughts?
ReplyDelete