Monday, July 27, 2026

Hope In The Library and the Age of AI; Proceed With Caution

 




Inspired by Chapter 6,“Living Libraries” from Hope in the Library: How Libraries Can Help Shape Our Future with Artificial Intelligence by Michael J. Paulus Jr.

Of all the chapters listed in Hope in the Library, the one that most "called" to my heart was the essence of Chapter 6: “Living Libraries.” The title itself wonderfully personifies this entity.  Author Michael J. Paulus Jr. the suggests that libraries are much more than buildings, databases, or collections of books; They are living, "breathing" foundations built upon human relationships, shared knowledge, and community engagement. Paulus opens his prologue likening the arrangement of books on shelves in Thomas Jefferson's library to that of the mind as used by Francis Bacon; "The books, encased on shelves forming a spiral, are arranged under three categories: history, philosophy and fine arts. Jefferson's classification scheme follows one proposed some two hundred years ago by Francis Bacon, who organized knowledge into what he considered to be the primary faculties of the mind used in studying various subjects: memory for history, reason for philosophy and science, and imagination for creative works. For Bacon, the world was like a set of books, and all our cognitive capabilities are required to understand what is revealed in them. (Paulus, P.11)

 In an era increasingly shaped by artificial intelligence, I believe human connection on all levels is more important than ever. What makes a library “living” is not simply the information it contains, but the people who give that information meaning. Libraries serve as gathering places where individuals from diverse backgrounds come together to learn, exchange ideas, and support one another. They preserve stories, experiences, and cultural knowledge while also creating opportunities for new conversations and discoveries. Unlike a search engine or AI system that simply provides answers, libraries foster communication, dialogue, empathy, critical thinking, and human connection. Hartley Burr Alexander who collaborated with architect Lee Lawrie on the iconographic program for the Los Angeles Public Library famously quoted "Books invite all; they constrain none." (Orlean 2018, P. 183)

Paulus writes "We experience reality, and discover and create meaning with others in the world, through shared recollections, imagining and reasoning. For millennia, we have depended on books and libraries taht provide access to them to extend what we know and experience - not only as individuals, but throughout societies. Beyond the years of one life or the decades of a family's survival, libraries measure time at the scale of centuries and millennia. To cultivate a full experience of human temporality - encounters with time that transcend the fragmented and fleeting experiences of individual lives - libraries preserve and create memories of the past, expectations of the future, and present understandings of the world. To encounter a library is to engage with archives of the past, anticipations about the future, and agency for action in the present. (Paulus, P. 11)

 

This chapter highlights the role of librarians as knowledge and cultural builders who guide us along the path. In a world where information is constantly expanding and misinformation can become disinformation and spread like a wildfire, embracing the skills needed to navigate information, evaluate and find trust-worthy sources are invaluable. Libraries empower people not only to access knowledge but also to understand and apply it thoughtfully. "This book is about these core functions of the library - as an archive, as a site of anticipation, and as a place of action - and why this unique institution remains especially important in the age of artificial intelligence." (Paulus, P.13)

The concept of “living libraries” is crucial in the age of artificial intelligence because it reminds us that the ultimate strength comes from the people inside. While AI can process vast amounts of information in mere seconds, it cannot replace the sense of belonging, safety and trust that libraries create within communities in every city universally. Technology, games, books and databases are all very important and very relevant tools, but the greatest value libraries offer is when individuals are connected to ideas, voices, and each other.

     A library offers a space of vibrancy, where people can engage with one another, ask questions, share experiences, and gain perspectives that technology alone cannot provide. In this way, libraries complement technological advances by ensuring that learning remains rooted in human values and relationships. Using Artificial intelligence to automate repetitive tasks such as cataloging, metadata generation, resource discovery, and reference assistance are the benefitting factors of this technology and most helpful to the library community.

     Rubin (2020) points out a seemingly obvious assumption: "Today we can be certain of only two things: technological changes will continue unabated, and they will occur at an accelerated pace." Rubin specifically highlights Lynch (2000) who identified four important technological developments in the modern library: (1) computerizing library operations such as circulation and ordering; (2) introducing technologies to improve public access such as the Online Public Access Catalog (OPA ), which also promoted union catalogs and resource sharing; (3) converting print content to electronic format, and (4) developing sophisticated networks providing anytime, anyplace access to digital information through the ever-developing and expanding internet. To this list, Yuvaraj (2015) added cloud computing. More recently King (2018) identified additional transformations: cashless payment systems (PayPal, Android Pay); downloadable and streaming media using Hulu, Netflix, Spotify, and YouTube, which eliminates the need to buy CDs and DVDs; computing-related adaptations (apps, tablets, smartphones); and the social web (Facebook, Twitter)." These efficiencies can free librarians to spend more time on what humans do best: teaching information literacy, helping patrons navigate complex issues, building community relationships, and promoting intellectual freedom. [libraryjournal.com], [ala.org] 

 

 

Libraries must however, resist the temptation to view AI as a librarian replacement. The American Library Association's guidance on AI explicitly states that AI should support library services while preserving human judgment, accountability, and professional values.  [ala.org], [ala.org] Libraries prioritize human connection as much as they do access to information, providing one of the few trusted public spaces where people can receive support without the pressures of money-making motives or algorithmic bias.

As AI-generated content becomes increasingly common, people will need trusted guides to help distinguish reliable information from misinformation and deepfakes. Library professionals are uniquely positioned to fill this role. Experts speaking at the 2026 American Library Association conference argued that libraries may be among the most trusted institutions capable of helping communities navigate the risks and opportunities of AI. [libraryjournal.com]

Matt Ellis, Senior Editor, Technology for Library Journal reported on "The Ethical AI in Libraries; A Critical Look at the Promise and Potential" panel at the 2026 American Library Association (ALA) Conference and Exhibition in Chicago. The panel covered artificial intelligence as a dominating issue that librarians must contend with "for the sake of their patrons and their institutions. There are problems, risks, and opportunities that should be addressed proactively."

Michael Hanegan, Founder of the Center for the Future of Learning and Work, said during the panel discussion, “Disengaging with AI guarantees your vulnerability, and it guarantees harm to your position. So even if you don’t like it, even if you don’t want to use it, the people that you serve will be harmed without your help."

Micah May, director of business development for Lyrasis, noted that "AI is becoming increasingly ubiquitous in the tools that both patrons and librarians use regularly, including internet search, research tools, discovery, readers’ advisory, virtual assistants, cataloging, metadata, and archival processing. He added, “at the same time, we all recognize that there are real problems and conflicts with our [library] values around privacy, data surveillance, algorithmic bias, digital equity…environmental issues, not to mention more dramatic potential threats.”

In my view, the future library should be a place where patrons not only access AI tools but also learn how those tools work, where they fail, and what ethical concerns they raise. Libraries should become leaders in AI literacy, just as they have long been leaders in information literacy.

In a recent article written in AI & Society, the forum proposes that libraries should promote ethical AI literacy and human-centered learning rather than simply providing technological access. Researchers suggest that libraries must help citizens understand algorithmic bias, transparency, accountability, and the societal implications of AI technologies. [link.springer.com], [link.springer.com]

"The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into libraries represents a transformative evolution in knowledge creation, access, and collaboration .By integrating emotional intelligence (EQ) into AI tools and fostering user agency, libraries can empower individuals to critically evaluate AI outputs while preserving intellectual and creative autonomy. Practical strategies, such as workshops, interdisciplinary collaboration, and institutional policy development, demonstrate how libraries can operationalize ethical AI integration to promote transparency, intellectual freedom, and cultural inclusivity. Ultimately, this paper positions libraries as dynamic hubs for ethical knowledge creation and equitable human–machine collaboration, ensuring that emerging technologies amplify collective progress and innovation while aligning with human values." (Ellixson, 2026). 

I believe this is one of the most important responsibilities libraries will have during the coming decades. Many people use AI systems without understanding how they generate answers, collect data, or potentially reinforce biases, so libraries can then offer these workshops, community discussions, and educational programs to patrons rather than just passing along useless AI-generated information.This educational mission reflects the "living" aspect of libraries. Instead of merely distributing information, libraries can cultivate informed, engaged citizens capable of participating thoughtfully in a technology-driven society.

Another reason libraries should remain humanistic is their long-standing commitment to privacy and intellectual freedom. AI systems frequently depend on large-scale data collection and monitoring. This creates potential conflicts with library values. UNESCO's guidance on generative AI emphasizes the importance of maintaining human agency, protecting privacy, and ensuring ethical and equitable use of AI technologies. Similarly, the American Library Association recommends careful evaluation of AI systems to safeguard privacy, equity, accessibility, and public trust. [unesco.org], [cedefop.europa.eu] [ala.org], [ala.org]

For this reason, I believe libraries should adopt AI cautiously and transparently. Patrons should know when AI is being used, what data are being collected, and how decisions are being made. Human oversight should always remain available. This is the heart of the chapter that spoke to me because it captures what I believe is the essence of librarianship: people helping people learn, grow, and connect. While AI offers powerful new tools, the future of libraries should not be defined by technology alone. Instead, libraries should shape the future by using AI to enhance human service, expand digital literacy, and strengthen community engagement.

In my educated opinion, the most successful libraries of the future will be those that embrace innovation while remaining firmly rooted in human values. AI may change how information is organized and accessed, but libraries must continue to be places where curiosity, empathy, critical thinking, and human connection thrive. That is what will keep them truly "living libraries" in the age of artificial intelligence.

References

  • American Library Association. Guidance on the Use of Artificial Intelligence in Libraries (2026). [ala.org], [ala.org]
  • King, David Lee. 2018. "How to Stay on Top of Emerging Technology Trends for Librarians." Library Technology Reports 54 (February/March). Chicago: American Library Association.
  • Library Journal. “Ethical Use of AI in Libraries” (2026). [libraryjournal.com]
  • Lynch, Clifford, 2000. "From Automation to Transformation." Educase Review 35 (January/February): 60-68.
  • Michalak, R., Ellixson, D. Reimagining libraries in the AI era: ethical AI literacy and human-centered strategies. AI & Soc 41, 5057–5077 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-025-02827-4
  • Orlean, S. (2018). The library book. Simon & Schuster. P.183
  • Paulus, Michael J., Jr. Hope in the Library: How Libraries Can Help Shape Our Future with Artificial Intelligence (2026). [bloomsbury.com], [libraryjournal.com]
  • UNESCO. (2012) Guidance for Generative AI in Education and Research (2023). [unesco.org], [unesdoc.unesco.org]
  • “Reimagining Libraries in the AI Era: Ethical AI Literacy and Human-Centered Learning” (AI & Society). [link.springer.com], [link.springer.com
  • Rubin, R. E., & Rubin, R. G. (2020). Foundations of library and information science (5th ed.). ALA Neal-Schuman. (P. 197).
  • Yuvaraj, Mayank. 2015. "Cloud Computing Software and Solutions for Libraries: A Comparative Study." Journal of Elctronic Resources in Medical Libraries 12:25-41.

 

 

 

 

 

2 comments:

  1. I loved this chapter too! I loved how it was just describing that libraries are very much alive, and how they are so much more than buildings. I loved what you said here, " In an era increasingly shaped by artificial intelligence, I believe human connection on all levels is more important than ever. What makes a library “living” is not simply the information it contains, but the people who give that information meaning. Libraries serve as gathering places where individuals from diverse backgrounds come together to learn, exchange ideas, and support one another. They preserve stories, experiences, and cultural knowledge while also creating opportunities for new conversations and discoveries. Unlike a search engine or AI system that simply provides answers, libraries foster communication, dialogue, empathy, critical thinking, and human connection." That is so true, and I believe this chapter in Hope In The Library perfectly incorporates this feeling. Its one of the reasons I want to become a librarian. Great quotes and wonderful reflection. Very well written.

    ReplyDelete
  2. How will we ensure greedy corporations who own the AI and our not-so-courageous politicians follow these ethical precepts, too, fostering humanistic use? That will be our challenge, or is our challenge! I know you all will meet it!

    ReplyDelete